Skip to content

Back to All Blogs

October 29, 2026

Is Your Website Working Against You In the Age of AI?

Avatar photo

By Laura Dunn

Laura Dunn, CEO & Chief Brand Strategist

By Laura Dunn, Founder, CEO & Chief Brand Strategist, Dunn Marketing 

Most websites don’t break all at once; they drift. A staff page that still lists someone who left last spring. A contact form that quietly stopped sending emails in August. 

In the age of AI, your website behaves like a public operating system, connecting your ideas, authority, partnerships, content, and reputation. When those pieces line up, search, social, referrals, and even relationships all get easier. When they don’t, you have a real problem. 

So how do you know when to redesign your website, or whether a refresh will do? 

First, understand that the hub has flipped 

For years, marketers (me included) put the website at the center of every diagram, with every other channel pointing traffic back to it. That model has turned inside out. Your website is now where your content launches from, making you discoverable wherever people already are. 

This is the zero-click environment up close. Similarweb data analyzed by SparkToro found 68% of U.S. Google searches ended without a click from January through April 2026, and Ahrefs found AI Overviews now cost the top-ranking page 58% of its clicksaZqs. 

So give real value wherever people meet you, social posts included, without forcing a click. Keep some of your “secret sauce” on your site as a reason to visit. Just don’t gatekeep all of it. 

How many people use AI to search? 

  • Everyday adoption. 44% of U.S. adults use ChatGPT, up from 18% in 2023 (Pew Research Center, 2026). 
  • Local decisions. 45% of consumers used AI tools for local business recommendations, up from 6% a year earlier (BrightLocal, 2026). 
  • Google’s own AI. AI Overviews reach more than 2.5 billion people a month, and AI Mode has passed 1 billion (Google I/O 2026). 
  • Citations count. Pages cited in an AI Overview earn about 2.1% click-through, versus roughly 0.9% for uncited pages (Seer Interactive, 2026). 

8 signs you need a new website (a website refresh checklist) 

  • You don’t show up in ChatGPT, or AI gets your story wrong. Ask ChatGPT, Gemini, and Google’s AI Mode what your clients ask, like “Who offers estate planning in Windham County, CT?” Learning how to show up in ChatGPT starts with checking whether you do. 
  • Your site can’t answer your audience’s top 10 questions. List the questions you hear most. Any your site doesn’t answer plainly, in text, belongs in your content plan. 
  • Key information is trapped in images or PDFs. Google says important content should be available as text. A JPEG flyer of your schedule doesn’t count. 
  • Your details don’t match across the web. Hours, address, phone, and services should match your Google Business Profile and directory listings. 
  • It’s a chore on a phone. Try it one-handed, then run your homepage through Google’s free PageSpeed Insights. 
  • It looks abandoned. An old blog, last year’s events, or a team page full of people who’ve left tells visitors and AI systems you may not be current. 
  • It sounds like everyone else. Google rewards what it calls “non-commodity” content: first-hand experience and a real point of view over generic tips. 
  • Nobody knows whether it’s working. Search Console’s Generative AI performance report shows how your pages appear in AI Overviews and AI Mode. 

How often should you redesign your website? 

There’s no magic number of years. Most organizations need steady attention instead: a quarterly pass through this checklist, updates when services or staff change, and a bigger refresh when several signs show up at once. Rebuild when the platform itself is the problem. 

What best practice says (and what you can skip) 

AIO, GEO, and AEO (AI, generative engine, and answer engine optimization) all describe getting found and cited in AI answers. Google’s July 2026 guidance is blunt: for Google, that’s still SEO. You don’t need an llms.txt file, special AI markup, or chopped-up content. You do need crawlable pages, clear headings, helpful content written for people, structured data that matches the page, and a current Google Business Profile. Other AI platforms work differently and this keeps shifting, but clear, accurate, useful content wins everywhere. 

Why AI search is really a relationship lesson 

AI discoverability has pushed all of this into hyperspeed and raised the stakes on trust. When AI can summarize your reviews and answer a prospect’s question before they reach you, any gap between what you say and what you deliver shows. 

So start where we always have at Dunn Marketing: communicate the way you would in a personal relationship. Be real and up-front. Care about what matters in your audience’s lives and the role you play in it. Be honest about where you fall short and how you’re working to fix it. 

Here’s the part that excites me. AI discoverability hinges on knowing the questions your audience asks, about your service and the life events around it, like a family researching memory care or a retiree wondering whether they need a financial advisor. Getting found teaches you about the people you serve. Act on that, and your service, relationships, and organization all get better. It’s a golden chance to use AI to do better, technically and humanly. 

Here’s the thing about a refresh 

A refresh doesn’t always mean starting over. Often it’s rewriting five key pages, cleaning up listings, and planning answers to the questions people already ask. We just went through our own with the launch of our new dunnmarketing.com, so we know how much a refresh brings to the surface. 

At Dunn Marketing, our Empathy-Driven Brand Building™ approach starts with the people you serve. From our office in Danielson, we help organizations across Connecticut and Rhode Island build websites that are easy to find and easy to quote, then use what they learn to grow their impact. Reach out for a consultation. We’d love to help you connect, inspire, and convert. 

It’s a lot – let us help.

AI may have been utilized for the initial research and drafting of this content.

Sources 

Google Search Central, AI features and your website: https://developers.google.com/search/docs/appearance/ai-features 

* indicates required